by Melissa MacVicar
YA / Contemporary
Get a copy here!
After a notorious school shooting leaves her a shadow of the girl she once was, seventeen-year-old Lizzie Beringer moves to Nantucket Island. There, Lizzie is determined to keep her identity as the shooter’s sister a secret. All her efforts to fly under the radar, however, are complicated by her PTSD and her treatment at the hands of two very different boys. While fending off the unwanted advances of John Wickersham, she must also deal with her growing feelings for her brooding lab partner Gage Pike. Gage may act like he’s all wrong for her but the pull between them is undeniable.
Under the threat of discovery and the possibility of testifying in a televised trial, Lizzie attempts to pick up the broken pieces of her life.
One Broken Day is a brilliantly imagined story about the ways we are all broken and the miracle of second chances.
Melissa was born and mostly raised on Nantucket Island, and she currently lives there with her husband and two teenage children. When not being a wife and mother and teaching writing to seventh graders, she enjoys binge watching shows like Big Little Lies, House of Cards, and Outlander.
Despite the rumors to the contrary, she does not actually wish she was a teenager again, nor does she see ghosts like the main character in her first novel, Ever Near. She does, however, love to hear from readers so send her a message on social media or at her email!email: firstname.lastname@example.orgTwitter: @MelissaMacVicar
Facebook: Melissa MacVicar
Quick Reasons: LIFE-RUINER ALERT!; this was an emotionally challenging read; I can understand the motivations behind the character choices; the upheaval in Lainey/Lizzie’s life is obvious from page one; I couldn’t put this down
Huge thanks to Melissa MacVicar and YA Bound Book Toursfor sending me a free egalley of this title in exchange for an honest review! This in no way altered my read of or opinions on this book.
This was SUCH an emotionally challenging, haunting read. I finished this several days ago and have been struggling to put my thoughts into coherent words, because OH MY PENGUINS, this read! I was drawn into the turmoil from page one, ensnared and enchanted by the tragedies of the situation–and the reactions of the world. Melissa MacVicar did a stupendous job thrusting readers straight into Lainey/Lizzie’s head, and I applaud her so much for it. Truly, I was captivated just as much as I was heartbroken. Coming out of this read, I can see the motivations behind certain decisions Melissa MacVicar made for her characters and their coping mechanisms. Having grown up in a household of addiction, it was even easier for me to see into the heart of the recreational drug use that occurs throughout this read. (Of course, this doesn’t mean I necessarily condone such coping mechanisms–just that I understand why the characters react the way they do)
I feel the strength of this novel lies in the characters–and the different ways they grow and shift throughout this journey. However, there’s a sense of mystery and suspense woven through every page–a motivation that kept me trapped, unable to put the book down. While we don’t necessarily get handed all the “answers,” I feel Melissa MacVicar did this with a purpose–life, after all, doesn’t always just hand us a reason or justification for why people do the things they do, or why things happen the way they do. So while a lot of other readers are calling for “more” depth to this read… I applaud Melissa MacVicar for not trying to force a solution where, sometimes, there just ISN’T one.
This was a desperate, twisting path of emotions–and I cherished every moment for reminding me that the world isn’t always black and white. That there are grey areas where answers are elusive and human reactions don’t always make sense. I will, for sensitive or easily triggered readers, put a slight mature content warning out there–recreational drug use and sex, along with bullying and suicidal thoughts, are prevalent throughout and play a large role in this read. Please keep yourselves safe.
I am awed by how powerfully poignant and heart-wrenching this read from Melissa MacVicar is, and cannot wait to see what the future holds for her creatively. While there are some grammatical errors, there weren’t enough of them to break my concentration or bother me. The characters and their reactions are vividly painted and, at least in my opinion, realistically written. I definitely recommend to lovers of emotionally challenging reads, characters struggling to cope with heavy burdens, and twisting plot vines. Look deeper, Penguins; there’s more to these words than meets the eye.